After my all-time, favorite lip balm/treatment was discontinued (Prescriptives Lip Specialist), I began this hunt...a sojourn, if you will...to find a replacement for it. Sadly, there really isn't anything that I've come across that is as similar in efficacy, formula, etc. I've found a couple products that are good enough, but nothing nearly as successful in treatment as I had with Px Lip Specialist. A lot of hearts were broken when Estee Lauder Co. pulled the plug on that brand, and I'm definitely one of them. At any rate, I will break down my thoughts and experiences with some drugstore and higher end lip balms/treatments, in hope that I save someone/anyone else some time and money. And aggravation, frustration, so on.

I've been using Neutrogena's lip balm for several years. It doesn't have much of a scent and isn't overly waxy. It makes for a good lipstick base and contains SPF 15, which is always a good thing. It's definitely a moisturizer, rather than a healer. It works more as maintenance for lips that are already in decent condition. Do I love this stuff? Not really. But I like it enough to keep buying and using it.
Mode de Vie Shea Butter Vanilla Lip Balm is a pretty recent find of mine. It doesn't contain anything that would irritate me (beeswax, lanolin, or mint oils), so for that very reason, I like it. Not love, but definite like. The pleasant vanilla scent is an added bonus. Again, more of a light moisturizer and less of a healer.
I was really excited when Aquaphor released this a few months ago. It's definitely more of a lip balm, in comparison to the original Aquaphor Healing Ointment that many people use for lip care. This Lip Repair has some shea butter and other oils mixed in, which gives it a lighter feel and glossier consistency. This is definitely a day balm (for me, at least), as I don't find it to be "healing". Nonetheless, it works well enough as a daytime moisturizer.
This is currently my night treatment aka the only thing that actually heals my lips and keeps them in decent shape. It's mostly petrolatum (Vaseline) with some stuff like mineral oil and glycerin to make it more emollient. Also, the packaging alone makes it more appealing and more hygienic, in comparison to standard Vaseline in tub form.
I was actually really surprised when I liked C.O. Bigelow Rose Salve. I had been reading about people loving to use these types of salves on their lips, but I never found it very appealing or appetizing, as a lot of rose scented lip products make me gag. This stuff is very soothing, but not terribly moisturizing or healing. It's a product best used to maintain lip moisture or calm the burning feeling one can get from dry and abused lips. The rose scent is sweetened, which makes it non-repulsive for my hyper-sensitive olfactory receptors.

I thought that the über-hyped By Terry Baume de Rose would be my chapped lip salvation...the end of the search. False. I made the mistake of not reading the ingredient list before purchasing, only to find out after my tongue started itching that it contained lanolin, of which I'm very much allergic to. The thing that kind of confuses me about this product is why they would feel the need to throw in an ingredient that many are sensitive or allergic to. There's so many other lovely and emollient ingredients...why throw in cheap wool's oil? The logic is missing. Result? Le fail.

After the By Terry debacle, I thought..okay..La Mer it is. I've read rave reviews from celebrities, makeup artists, and normal consumers, so I thought this would be a done deal. Incorrect. This stuff is, for a lack of a better term, overpriced crap. I genuinely can't understand the following this product commands. I slathered it on my lips with hope, and that hope quickly died after my lips starting burning like holy fury. The ingredient that really killed this product for me was the eucalyptus oil. I know a lot of people love the tingle they get with mint infused lip balms/treatments, but this was insane. My lips felt as though they were set afire. It wasn't much fun. Burning mouth aside, the texture itself is kind of rough and doesn't seem to melt into the skin very well. It's much too waxy, in my opinion. Fiery fail.

So the La Mer didn't work out, whatever. I was surprised, but thought Chanel would be able to end the quest, as I love so many of their other products. Faux. This is a wildly pointless product. I was shocked by how ineffective and useless it was. I didn't have any allergic reactions or sensitivities to the Hydramax balm, but it did absolutely nothing to moisturize my lips. In fact, I think they felt more dry the morning after I applied it. The part that I really couldn't handle was the disgusting, rancid, fake candy scent/flavor they gave this balm. The taste just lingered in my mouth as I was trying to get to sleep, and no amount of water would lessen the vile flavor. Again, fail.

Annoyed and disgruntled by all the previous "high end" efforts, I gave this Clarins Lip & Contour balm a go, feeling as if I had nothing to lose. Wrong. This garbage made my mouth itch. It doesn't contain any beeswax or lanolin, so I don't know what ingredient aggravated my mouth. What I do know is that after reading the ingredient list, this stuff is formulated with a bunch of really cheap oils and additives. More failure.
So after all those dept. store failures, I thought, why not? Let's do this flower child dance. So, I bought a big 'ole tub of raw, unrefined shea butter and slathered it all over my mouth. The result? GROSS!! It smelled like a dead hippy and felt like it was infused with sand. Earth mother fail xs 1000.
Going from one extreme to the next, I thought it best that I just try some drugstore products that others seem to have a lot of luck with. My thoughts on Nivea balms? Not so great. It feels okay on the lips, but I hate the way these are scented. I've tried various scents/flavors and formulations within the brand, and I've hated them all. Drugstore fail.
Two words: Organic beeswax. Buzzzz. Fail. Next.
I like that Smith's decided to give consumers the option of sticking their grubby fingers in the tins or allowing them the hygienic luxury of using a tube, but I just don't like this one. I much prefer the scent and feel of C.O. Bigelow's Rose Salve. Alas, fail.
I will love you forever, Px Lip Specialist. May you rest.
So in conclusion, Aquaphor and a couple other random brands work for me, but the majority of products out on the market do not. Whoever said life was fair? Such words were certainly never muttered from my dry, allergy-prone lips.
Any lip balm/treatment recommendations? I could obviously use them.
xxx ~R